| |
This book speaks about a most powerful phenomenon in social
life, religion, regarding it as one of the strongest and
most productive motifs in human life. This book deals with
religion from its sociological point of view. It shows in
part 1 that myth and rituals are tools that assist in the
reception, and strengthening of religion, which together
create a morality that enables people to live in society.
They, together, form the wellspring of society. Since society,
as will be elucidated later, has existed from the beginning
of human life; religion , myth and ritual - together with
speech - have also existed, as will be seen in parts 1 and
9, since the beginning of mankind. It will be concluded
that all these exist today and willcontinue to exist till
the end of humanity. Ethnic groups may be crystallized,
within the context of certain religions, myths, rituals,
language, arts, and sentiments- into a religion and its
byproducts - and nations follow the same course, with the
additional help of ethnicity, and lately, with the help
of the state. Modern states are involved in creating new
nations in order to survive. It will be shown how the endeavors
of modern states are problematic, as will be described in
parts 3,4,6,8 of the book. There is a difference in strength
between civil religions, ideological religions, and theistic
religions; and concerning the last-mentioned, differences
in strength between polytheistic religions and monotheism.
No discussion of ethics, which is described in part 5 of
the book, and nationalism, can take place without relating
to religion.
A person reading this book may well imagine that it was
written in the aftermath of the September 11, 2001 World
Trade Center explosion in New York. The fact is that though
this book opens a window into answers not yet proposed to
many of the questions that that tragedy has raised; it was
mostly written before that.
This book deals with the main anthropological and religious
researchers (I'm not sure if you are referring to the studies
or the people researching, if to the studies replace "researches"
with studies- D. F) in the West who investigate the source
of religions as well asthe social and individual phenomena
of the religious creed, its outgrowths, especially in the
fields of morality and nationality, as well as the variant
and particular characteristics of different religions. Comparing
the different routes of several religions, it appears that
nobody in the West has put enough emphasis on the huge power
and the complete spectrum of social byproducts hidden within
the phenomenon of religion. It appears also that nobody
in the West has understood, until now, that without religion
there is no humanity. Only few imagined how that phenomenon
became part of human life; not one of them has understood
the basic truth, viz. that that phenomenon was a "must"
for humanity andit is going to last for as long as humanity
lasts.
Not many have understood that it is difficult to form a
nation with no common religion (in the broadest meaning
of that word, including religions with no God, like civil
religion) as its basis. It appears, too, that what many
imagine is a nation, is in fact a group at the beginning
stages of its nationhood that is trying to create a nation
out of its state's civil society.
It appears that no single thinker in the west has understood
the common ground of all secular moral thinkers of the West
and the common ground of all monotheistic religious (of
Israelite origin) morals. Within that discussion this book
reveals some special measure of morality that is unique
to Jewish morality.
This book is made up of 9 parts, 4 volumes. The central
message is that religion is a force that is indispensable
to the formation, existence, and true source of any human
group. The 4 volumes and 9 parts are as follows:
Volume I: The origins of Society - Religion and Myth
Part
1: Religion and Society
Part
2: Myth and Religion
Volume II: Products of religion - morality, ethnic Groups,
nations
Part
3: Nation
Part
4: Ethnic Groups
Part
5: Morality and Religion
Volume III: Specific Social Products
Part
6: Black Africa
Part
7: Imperial China
Part
8: Latin America
Volume IV: Religion and the Believer
Part
9: Religion itself
Part
1 starts with an anthropological review of why divine religions
came into being among humans, and incorporates a long-range
historical review and a forecast based on a realistic look
at the present, at modern life.
Part
2 deals with myths and their religious tasks. It speaks
about their formation of societies, whether religious, national
(ethnic or states') or cultural, the way it (together with
rituals) defines the humane borders of societies, how they
make the members of a society to feel as if they know each
other closely, feel sympathy and solidarity.
Part
3 speaks about the notion and term of Nation and the influence
of religion on it.
Part
4 speaks about ethnic groups and their relations with religion.
Part
5 speaks about morals and their relationship with religion.
Part
6 deals with primitive religions, spirits and witchcraft.
Part
7 deals with Imperial China and the West as a comparative
case from which one can understand the great influence of
different attitudes to religion and God.
Part
8 deals with Latin America in comparison to the United States
on one hand and to Canada on the other hand, and a comparison
between the United States and Canada. The discussion is
about the influence of religions, for example, the different
attitude to native Indians. It comes that the motif of introverted
hierarchical relations of the people of catholic tradition
enabled the settlers in south and center America to occupy
their part of America with no genocide policy. They mostly
could come to America without female partners, taking Indian
females to be wives, while the idea of equality inherited
by the English settlers could not mary Indian women and
practiced, actually according to a genocide way. They could
not, mentally, arrange equal way of life with Indians.
Part
9 deals with religion itself.
The book considers and searches for answers for basic questions
about the social life many have not yet been dealt with
or elucidated in the Secular Western Thought, questions
that relate to religion from a social perspective.
The salient of these questions, that inverts Religion to
be in the focus of social life, even in our Modern Society,
are as follows:
1. 'Why religion?' - What interests, pressures, or needs
impelled man to seek a connection with other worlds? Why
couldn't man exist, in general, and as a social being specifically
- before he formed a spiritual connection with God or with
an entity that was beyond his realm of existence? Why did
man desire and need to heed the voice of his God and the
moral obligations imposed upon him, according to his beliefs,
by his God? Why does human society - every human
society - need to find something that is not from the world
where man leaves, that cannot be proven to believe in and
to follow (The book termed this religion, even if it is
a belief in liberalism, communism, or Zionism). Why does
Biblical-Christian religious morality exist even among secular
people in the West? Why has modern Western men failed to
design a moral code that would replace the Judeo-Christian
tradition that shapes the lives of their societies today?
2. Among all the components of nationalism, what degree
of salience does religion, ethnicity, language, economic
interests each have? How do these different factors interact?
How does a religion create a nation, expand its sphere of
influence, or change its essence?.
3. What happens to a country that has no nation? How does
it create one for itself?
4. What characteristics are shared by all Western systems
of morality and how do they differ from divinely inspired
systems of morality?
5. The struggle between secular and divine religions. The
United States of America emasculating the divine religions,
and bars them from any possibility of involvement in or
connection to the government of the country, trampling on
the rights of the Catholic and Jewish educational systems
as part of the religious war it wages.
6. Western materialism and utilitarianism in contrast to
Judaism's moral educational system.
7. Modernity versus tradition. The spiritual advantages
of tradition and the scientific and technological advantages
of modernity. Western world's inability to comprehend the
traditional world of native Africans.
8. A comparison between African nepotism and Israeli-American
nepotism (protective policy).
9. Understanding the difference between a tribe with roots
in a primitive religion and an ethnic group whose religion
thrives to embrace the world.
10. The difference between ethnicity and nationalism.
11. The standing of primitive tribes in a world of advancing
nationalities
12. Ethnic and religious roots of aggression
13. Aggressive and non-aggressive religions
14. More resilient and less resilient religions.
It becomes clear how unrealistic the attempt is to eradicate
divine religion from nationalism or even from civil religion.
Hence any comprehensive discussion of these matters must
include discussion of the essence of divine religion, civil
religion, nationalism, and ethics.
The approach to the substance, like the book itself, was
not made up according to an ordered plan. So it was because
I would not dare from the beginning to come to a conclusion
to write a systematic book of research to compete with the
huge and most ambitious task as it came to be at the end
of the day. The whole thing came out like the calf that
sprang out in front of Aaron, the brother of Moses. In the
course of last six years of research for PHD decree in constitutional
Law in the Hebrew University of Jerusalem I was free to
learn whatever I liked. Being interesting in the motif of
religion because of some personal motives I have, in every
Seminar of most of the 23 Seminars I participated I have
found a religious corner. It was far away from anything
like a plane. May be that it was hidden inside my bones,
may be it was within the human substance I thrived to understand,
yet, the same happened to the inside of the whole writing.
Not I was the planner, or the 'plotter'. Also, it is not
for me to explain why did I choose for example, Imperial
China or Latin America in order to prove with their assistance
how strong religion is. It could be the same with any other
part of the world or the history that could or could not
show by them the motive of strength coming out of the motif
of religion. Yet, may be, and that is no prove at all, that
in any thing I have search the motif of religion aroused,
with huge force, a possibility that religion is a phenomenon
that exists all over the human life, and is mostly dominant.
I suggest that the lack of a pre-organized plan for that
search is not an essential term without which conclusions
in this book cannot be accepted. In a retroactive look,
one may learn from the case of Aaron and his calf. There,
the wide range of grants given by many different people
who had the same intention or motivation, and that made
their common intention to be fulfilled. Likewise, in this
book, the composition of time and place, worldwide, speaks
in favor of the conclusions reached to in this book to conclude
that the picture from so different examples should teach
us about same common motifs inherent in different societies,
pointing at the common characteristics of religion. These
common characteristics, mainly, look unchanged, unchangeable,
any time, any place, in any circumstances.
|
|